I'm casting with my hands from the vessel of my heart
Out into the shallows where the world says the fish are
But I'm coming up so empty that I'm calling it a day
Cause even what I'm catching isn't filling up this place
In my heart there is a longing, like I'm made for something more
Than going back and forth between the water and the shore
But I'm caught up in these nets because it's all I've ever known
And if I tried to leave, I don't know if they'd let me go
Pride and pornography, lies and insecurity
Divorce and immorality, shame and all my guilty
Then You called to leave it all
I didn't get what You were saying and I had some hesitations
But You never got frustrated in your kindness You were patient
When I tripped over my sin
Wasn't the smoothest of transitions and I admit that I'm still slipping
But I promise I'm committed to Your different kind of fishing
It's just a hard first step
Where You're asking me to go is beyond my zone of comfort
It's a side I've never known but a feeling that I've wanted
Free from all the weight that pulls me down into the bottom
Now I'm deeper even still but it is not my fear that brought me
Out into these depths where the waves get really wicked
I am walking on the water cause I know that You are with me
Yeah, You called to leave it all
I didn't get what You were saying and I had some hesitations
But You never got frustrated in Your kindness You were patient
When I tripped over my sin
Wasn't the smoothest of transitions and I admit that I'm still slipping
But I promise I'm committed to Your different kind of fishing
And it's just a hard first step
Sun rising over Galilee, I'm sitting here next to the sea
The ripples reaching at my feet, I hear You whisper follow me
It's just a hard first step